Film Productions

Year Title Role Notes
2004 Halloweentown High Cody Trainer
2010 Twelve Warren
2014 Winter’s Tale Gabriel
Noah Young Tubal-cain
Unbroken Francis “Mac” McNamara
2015 My All American Freddie Steinmark Lead role
The Submarine Kid Spencer Koll
The Big Short Jamie Shipley
2016 La La Land Greg Earnest
2017 Landline Nate
A Midsummer Night’s Dream Demetrius
2018 A Futile and Stupid Gesture Tim Matheson
Jonny Collins Lead role
If Beale Street Could Talk Hayward
2019 Locating Silver Lake Seth Main role
Plus One Steve
The Last Black Man in San Francisco Clayton
Big Boy Pants Kyle Short film
Judy Mickey Deans
Semper Fi Jaeger
2020 Long Weekend Bart Post-production
Deep Water Nick
A Mouthful of Air Ethan Davis
Louie Young Roscoe Short film; post-production


Year Title Role
2003 Cold Case Eric Whitley in 1976
ER Thomas Yoder
2004 CSI: Miami Chad Van Horn
2009–11 All My Children Damon Miller
2011 Torchwood: Miracle Day Danny
2012 Harry’s Law Jimmy Cormack
Criminal Minds Harvey Morell
2013 Law & Order: Special Victims Unit Cameron Tyler
Masters of Sex Dale
2014 The Normal Heart Albert
2014–15 American Horror Story: Freak Show Dandy Mott
2015 Deadbeat Max
2015–16 American Horror Story: Hotel Tristan Duffy
Rudolph Valentino
2016 American Horror Story: Roanoke Jether Polk
2018 The Assassination of Gianni Versace: American Crime Story Jeffrey Trail
2019 Alternatino with Arturo Castro Eddie
American Horror Story: 1984 Bobby Richter
2020 Cake Himself
Ratched Edmund Tolleson
2021 American Horror Story: Season 10 TBA


Year Title Role Notes
2008 Candida Eugene Marchbanks Berkshire Theatre Festival
Romeo and Juliet Romeo Montague Shakespeare Theatre Company
2009 The Age of Iron Troilus Classic Stage Company
2011 The Illusion Calisto / Clindor / Theogenes Signature Theatre Company
2012 Death of a Salesman Harold “Happy” Loman Ethel Barrymore Theatre
The Blue Deep Jamie Williamstown Theatre Festival
Sweet Bird of Youth Chance Wayne The Goodman Theatre
2013 The Guardsman The Actor The Kennedy Center
2016 Othello Michael Cassio New York Theatre Workshop
2017 The Glass Menagerie Jim O’Connor Belasco Theatre